• Play
  • About
  • News
  • Forums
  • Yppedia
  • Help
Force Majeure

Puzzle Design: Analogies

After about a year to observe the Grand Crafting Puzzle Project where numerous designs have been proposed, refined, put together in play-test versions, further refined, and finally submitted for consideration from the developers, I believe I have finally reached the point where I am able to give some critical consideration to not just what makes a good puzzle design, but what makes a good Puzzle Pirates puzzle design.

What separates Puzzle Pirates from puzzle game collection sites is the degree of immersion. Every major activity has a puzzle, and every puzzle has a defined activity. As a standalone game, a puzzle may be or do anything. It does not need to represent anything at all. Indeed, some of the most invigorating puzzle games I have played are little more than a manipulation of lights and sounds with no connection to the world we inhabit.

Likewise, other MMORPGs may have similar activities, but rarely is every instance going to be defined by playing a game within the game. (Very often, when a friend or acquaintance has espoused the virtues of another game, I silently ask "What is it that you do when you fight something else?")

The critical point for Puzzle Pirates is the analogy of the puzzle. Every puzzle has elements to represent the activity it implies. The degree may vary significantly, from gunnery's nearly accurate depiction of the activity process to the subtle presence of the elements of wind, water, and rope in the sailing puzzle.

Within the crafting puzzles, the importance of the analogy is perhaps even stronger than in the rest of the game. Because the crafting puzzles are for a distinctly material activity, the sense of manipulating the components of the craft to make a finished product needs to be there. Because these puzzles are often intended to be more relaxing, the player will often have the chance to observe the analogy more easily and more critically.

Because of this, the analogy for a crafting puzzle must be quite strong to retain the sense of world. We could not, for instance, make a Tetris clone where the pieces were cloth cut-outs and call it tailoring. Well, we could, and it may make a fun puzzle, but it would not be a good tailoring puzzle. There is a need for the analogies to step further.

However, these are analogies, not simulations. I remember early on in the GCPP there were some designs submitted that seemed to cover the activity in question quite well. They were often quite elaborate, however upon a deeper consideration the question of what the puzzle elements would come forth. Despite mimicking the activity well, the designs were not true puzzles, but simulations. Within the context of a puzzle game they would not have worked.

Striking the balance in the analogy can be quite difficult. Go too far towards a simulation, and the puzzle aspect is lost, go too generic, and the feeling world placement is lost. I am not sure every puzzle within Puzzle Pirates have done the analogy perfectly, but they all do it rather well. As within the narrower context of the GCPP, so is it with the design of the game overall. There is a learning process for what does and does not work.

If this post is an overview of the style of design, next time I shall try to delve into the substance: the mechanics of design.


Posted by Domokun, Sage

Thanks Bia. I'm looking forward to the next entry.

October 31, 2007 at 09:30 AM PDT | permalink

Posted by felipe pereira

November 01, 2007 at 11:26 AM PDT | permalink

Posted by Pletoo

I, too, look forward to hearing more thoughts, particularly considering my involvement in the GCPP.

I find that when I am playing a game demo (no fear -they only get an hour of my time, if that) I often wonder if the basic gameplay would fit into a niche somewhere in the land of YPP. The vast majority of them would not, but I have found a few that would make interesting foundations. There are many places that I can go to play a variety of disjointed games. I love that YPP ties them together to make a world.

November 02, 2007 at 05:44 PM PDT | permalink

Posted by Burberry watches

http://www.iwcwatches.us/a.Lange-&-Sohne/ a.Lange & Sohne watch for sale
http://www.iwcwatches.us/audemars-Piguet/ audemars Piguet watch for sale
http://www.iwcwatches.us/Bell-&-Ross/ Bell & Ross watch for sale
http://www.iwcwatches.us/Breguet/ Breguet watch for sale
http://www.iwcwatches.us/Breitling/ Breitling watch for sale
http://www.iwcwatches.us/Burberry/ Burberry watch for sale

January 06, 2010 at 07:55 PM PST | permalink

Posted by discount ghd iv pure styler

we are Professional with the highest quality service.on-line manufacturer supplies that wholesales all kinds ghd mk4 gold styler,These cheaper coatings wear off very quickly and cause more damage to the hair ghd hair straightener is the world's famous brands and wholesale chi hair straightener. Our cheap chi flat iron,To give consumers convenient discount ghd iv dark styler,at the same time care of everyone's hair.ghd mk4 black styler,Its use is very simple,in case of leakage will automatically power off to protection of everyone's personal safety ghd iv purple styling set.are popular all over the world with high quality,When the temperature reaches a maximum ghd hot pink iv styler,it will not stop flashing the lights, reminding everyone.competitive price,In addition, the design was very nice, very lightweight.fast delivery.Dry autumn, is the hair of the most vulnerable physiological periods.shop online for,Welcome to visite our website. http://www.hairupstyler.com/

March 05, 2010 at 03:31 AM PST | permalink

Posted by cheap ghd iv kiss styler

We supply that wholesales all kinds cheap ghd hair straightener and ceramic hair irons are believed to be more gentle on the hair.discount chi hair straightener.on line.Our chi flat iron,Avatar is a 2009 American science fiction film written and directed by James Cameron ghd iv dark styler,Humans are engaged in mining Pandora's reserves of a precious mineral,wholesale ghd iv hot pink styler,are popular all over the world with high quality, competitive price, fast delivery.ghd iv purple styling set shop online for genuine & authentic hair straingtener,. It is an ideal tool for all your creative styling and finishing needs ghd mk4 black styler. Achieve a variety of looks and styles,ghd mk4 gold styler Welcome to visite our website. http://www.ghdhairon.com/

March 05, 2010 at 03:31 AM PST | permalink

Posted by Air Force Ones

Every day is blue day. If you encounter a setback, please look up to the sky, if only the sky is blue, you don't lose the hope.

November 15, 2010 at 06:42 AM PST | permalink

Post a Comment:

Comments are moderated for the benefit of all readers and published at the discretion of weblog owners. Our comment policy is here.

Comments are closed for this entry.

About this blog

Bia's Blog is a part of the Puzzle Pirates Blog Network. More...

Puzzle Pirates™ © 2001-2016 Grey Havens, LLC All Rights Reserved.   Terms · Privacy · Affiliates